Asynchronous vs. Deterministic Communication and Types of Motion Controller Topologies

Asynchronous vs. Synchronous CommunicationA motion control system is a system that controls the position, velocity, force or pressure of some machine.  As an example, an electromechanical based motion control system consists of a motion controller (the brains of the system), a drive (which takes the low power command signal from the motion controller and converts it into high power current/voltage to the motor), a motor (which converts electrical energy to mechanical energy), a feedback device (which sends signals back to the motion controller to make adjustments until the system produces the desired result), and a mechanical system (including actuators, which physically produce the desired end result).

A motion controller is the primary intelligence, or brain, within a motion control system.  It is responsible for calculating and generating the output commands for a desired motion path or trajectory. Motion controllers vary in complexity; sophisticated motion controllers typically consist of a trajectory generator (path planner), interpolator, and control loop for servo motor control.

Types of Motion Control Systems
Open Loop System – A system that does not use feedback to verify the desired result, or output, has been reached.  Most step motor systems are operated open loop.

Closed Loop System – A system that uses feedback to verify the desired result, or output, has been reached. As an example, a feedback device such as an encoder is commonly used to provide position or velocity information to a motion controller.  A servo motor system requires the use of a feedback  device.

Types of Motion Controller Topologies
PLC based motion controllers typically utilize a digital output device, such as a counter module, that resides within the PLC system to generate command signals to a motor drive.  They are usually chosen when simple, low cost motion control is required but are typically limited to a few axes and have limited coordination capabilities.

PC based motion controllers typically consist of dedicated hardware run by a real-time operating system.  They use standard computer busses such as PCI, Ethernet, Serial, USB, and others for communication between the motion controller and host system.  PC based controllers generate a ±10V analog output voltage command for servo control and digital command signals, commonly referred to as step and direction, for stepper control.  PC based motion controllers typically are used when high axes count and/or tight coordination is required.  The drawbacks of this topology include complex cabling and potentially long wiring distances between the drive and motor.

A fieldbus based motion controller topology consists of a communication interface device and intelligent drive(s).  The communication interface device typically resides within a PLC or PC system and connects to a single or multiple intelligent drives.  The drives contain all the functionality of the motion controller and function as a complete single axis system.  Often the drives can be daisy chained to other intelligent drives on the same fieldbus.  The benefits include all digital communication, detailed diagnostics, reduced cabling, high axes count and short wiring distance between the drive and motor.  This topology has a higher cost especially at lower axes count and has limitations providing tight coordination for multiple axes.  Examples of this topology include Profibus, DeviceNet, RS-232/485, and others.

Asynchronous vs. Deterministic Topology
Asynchronous communication is transmission of data, generally without the use of an external clock signal, where data can be transmitted intermittently rather than in a steady stream.  Asynchronous literally means not synchronous, meaning, data is not transmitted at regular intervals, thus making possible variable bit rate, and that the transmitter and receiver clock generators do not have to be exactly synchronized all the time.

Deterministic communication is the transmission of data reaching its destination in a specific, predicable time.  Time critical data transfer must be guaranteed within short and precise configurable cycles, while less critical data can be transmitted in asynchronous time slots.  Data reaching its destination at guaranteed times are critical for motion control.

A deterministic bus based motion controller topology splits the motion controller functionality across a communication interface device and intelligent drive via a deterministic digital network.  The communication interface device typically resides within a PLC or PC system and contains the trajectory generator.  The intelligent drives typically contain the control loop and interpolator and can be daisy chained to other intelligent drives on the same network.  The digital network is deterministic with low jitter to allow for tight coordination in multi axes applications.  The benefits include all digital communication, detailed diagnostics, reduced cabling, high axes count, tight coordination, and short wiring distance between the drive and motor.  This topology has a higher cost especially at lower axes count.  Examples of this topology include EtherCAT, SERCOS,  Ethernet Powerlink, PROFINET IRT, SynqNet, CANopen, and others.

Search our Motion and Automation Controllers by subcategory:

Search our Motion and Automation Controllers by supplier:

For more information, please contact:

EDITORIAL CONTACT:
Warren Osak
sales@electromate.com
Toll Free Phone:   877-737-8698
Toll Free Fax:       877-737-8699
www.electromate.com

0 Responses to “Asynchronous vs. Deterministic Communication and Types of Motion Controller Topologies”



  1. Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Archives

Subscribe to this blog by entering your email address below.

Join 666 other followers

Presentation Playlist

Flickr Photos

Blog Stats

  • 55,074 hits

%d bloggers like this: